Constant maturity indices
Why a perpetual on a fixed contract is ill posed.
A perpetual future has no expiry and is held to its index by periodic funding. Applying that construction to a single option contract fails, and not for an implementation reason.
Why a fixed contract cannot carry a perpetual
Let the index be the price of a contract expiring at T0. As t → T0 the index tends to the terminal payoff and time value tends to zero.
The index therefore carries a deterministic drift. Funding would have to offset theta in perpetuity, meaning the funding rate would be dominated by a known quantity rather than by the imbalance it exists to price. Past T0 the index is undefined. The instrument is ill posed, not merely awkward.
Holding the tenor fixed
Fix τ instead of fixing the contract, and re-derive the index from the current surface at every observation.
Since τ does not depend on t, there is no theta term. The index is a level in volatility points, not a decaying price. The same construction supports a rolling fixed delta call or an at the money straddle, quoted in currency.
One unit is one vega and exactly zero delta. Adding 100 units to a book carrying 12.27 vega and 84.86 delta produces 112.27 vega and leaves delta at 84.86, unchanged. Clean vega is otherwise obtainable only by running a hedged straddle and rebalancing it by hand.